Showing posts with label Dilbert. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dilbert. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Drunken Lemurs [Updated]

I had this posted in my office when it came out:


Just in case the image doesn't work... Dilbert is standing by a garbage man and asks him "Why does it seem as if most of the decisions in my workplace are made by a bunch of drunken lemurs?", to which the man replies "Decisions are made by the people who have the time, not people who have the talent". The final scene has Dilbert asking "Why are talented people so busy?" and gets the reply "They're fixing the problems made by people who have the time."

Apparently, the self-admitted Drunken Lemurs at the Catfish Bend Casino decided to lay a bunch of staff off, and one of their employees, David Steward, posted the cartoon on a bulletin board. These people with time, but no talent, were very offended at finding themselves represented in Dilbert, and fired Mr. Steward. It wound up in court, because they challenged his unemployment claim.

The judge, who apparently is not a Drunken Lemur, must have found this rather amusing, and sided with the employee.

Thankfully, my previous boss was not among the Drunken Lemurs crowd, because he found the comic amusing when I posted it at my cubicle.

[UPDATE] You may be interested in the moral of this story, as told by Dilbert author Scott Adams.

Monday, November 05, 2007

Why It Was A Good Idea To Attack Iraq

From the one and only Scott Adams, of Dilbert fame, comes "Why It Was a Good Idea to Attack Iraq". He begins:
Sometimes, just to test my point of view, I like to take the opposite side and defend it. For example, I think attacking Iraq was a huge mistake. So today I will make my best argument for the other side.

I must admit that I think he took most of this from Hillary. But, we'll let him have her argument, just this once.
First, you have to separate the outcome, which is unknown, from the original decision to attack. Hypothetically, it could be a good decision to attack, based on what you knew at the time, but things could go wrong for unforeseen reasons. Likewise, it could have been a bad decision to attack, based on the evidence at the time, and somehow by luck, things might turn out well. So you have to look at the decision and the outcome separately.

He seriously goes on to defend Bush's invasion of Iraq.
The cost of the war in Iraq is immense. But it has several potential benefits:

1. Al-Qaida showed itself to be everyone’s enemy.
2. Iraq has potential to be a U.S. ally, even if true democracy doesn’t take hold.
3. The U.S. sharpened its war-making tools and showed it is willing to use them.
4. Iraqi oil production will eventually increase, even if it takes 20 years.
5. The U.S. has a permanent military base in the Middle East.

He even says:
All things considered, the DECISION to attack Iraq was correct, given the perceived risk of Saddam developing WMD.

Oh, and here's the Republican argument:
When a venture capitalist invests in a particular company, and it goes out of business, he doesn’t conclude that he made a bad decision to invest. He concludes that his strategy is good because he only needs one in ten companies to succeed.

And to finish:
In fact, if we attacked three or four countries looking for WMD, and found none, it still doesn’t invalidate the strategy. You only need to find one country that actually has them, and might use them, to make the entire strategy sensible. At the very least, all that attacking gives some teeth to the U.N. inspectors.

That’s my best argument for why attacking Iraq was both sensible at the time and might work out well in the long run.

I just wish I believed it.

The last line is perfect. Read the whole thing, he says it better than I can copy/paste pieces of it. And if you've ever read Dilbert, you know how great Scott Adams is at trying to make sense of the nonsensical.